1.先验证剩余模型(1:vgg16、2:resnet20、3:fashion_lenet5、4:svhn_lenet5)onehot_refine_200_2000的矩阵经过降维之后是否能达到和lenet145一样惊艳的效果
1平均值 | 1最大值 | 1最小值 | 1方差 | 2平均值 | 2最大值 | 2最小值 | 2方差 | 3平均值 | 3最大值 | 3最小值 | 3方差 | 4平均值 | 4最大值 | 4最小值 | 4方差 | |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
5 | 0.740589474 | 2.248 | 0 | 0.247771316 | 0.757515789 | 6 | 0 | 0.942563808 | 0.893010526 | 4.046 | 0 | 0.422708347 | 4.675210526 | 8.947 | 1.792 | 2.391439935 |
6 | 0.724378947 | 3.709 | 0 | 0.626279267 | 1.510484211 | 6.93 | 0 | 0.855478523 | 2.367473684 | 5.316 | 1.329 | 0.443260102 | 4.476252632 | 10.204 | 2.384 | 4.169062105 |
7 | 0.751863158 | 2.945 | 0 | 0.416027087 | 0.777505263 | 3.39 | 0 | 0.376995955 | 0.530347368 | 2.247 | 0 | 0.2164449 | 4.159315789 | 9.792 | 2.289 | 2.190974132 |
8 | 0.567326316 | 2.439 | 0 | 0.291456136 | 0.365147368 | 1.961 | 0 | 0.115020062 | 1.6382 | 2.878 | 0 | 0.700995886 | 4.277936842 | 7.792 | 2.458 | 2.16826928 |
9 | 0.793052632 | 8.474 | 0 | 2.485374134 | 1.068884211 | 4.918 | 0 | 0.91478926 | 0.558578947 | 2.198 | 0 | 0.16518496 | 4.570968421 | 9.124 | 3.265 | 0.934614873 |
10 | 2.718768421 | 8 | 1.647 | 0.713631778 | 0.544252632 | 2.56 | 0 | 0.245795726 | 1.945378947 | 4.76 | 0.621 | 1.021884467 | 5.201989474 | 10.077 | 3.948 | 1.161112116 |
11 | 2.793010526 | 5.883 | 1.6 | 0.370812937 | 0.695915789 | 4.227 | 0 | 1.202680014 | 1.815684211 | 4.082 | 1.029 | 0.198789227 | 4.685252632 | 9.124 | 3.131 | 1.335107031 |
12 | 2.270621053 | 4.127 | 0.705 | 0.722178046 | 1.464894737 | 4.938 | 0 | 1.082229505 | 1.968894737 | 3.51 | 0 | 0.444277357 | 3.598515789 | 10.407 | 2.272 | 1.916254629 |
13 | 3.096010526 | 6.193 | 1.611 | 0.451414726 | 2.418515789 | 4.918 | 0.948 | 1.222774776 | 1.338231579 | 5.474 | 0.117 | 0.832848388 | 4.483852632 | 7.408 | 3.001 | 1.262053536 |
14 | 1.009368421 | 3.704 | 0 | 0.41090958 | 1.803557895 | 4.094 | 0 | 0.511157068 | 2.258936842 | 6.78 | 1.071 | 0.748519659 | 2.026631579 | 3.792 | 1.22 | 0.283672064 |
15 | 0.763252632 | 5 | 0 | 0.595609999 | 1.459736842 | 3.115 | 0 | 0.163317036 | 2.430084211 | 6.123 | 1.181 | 0.746071803 | 2.027284211 | 8.484 | 0.923 | 1.614454603 |
16 | 0.674884211 | 3.75 | 0 | 0.354594102 | 0.873168421 | 1.957 | 0 | 0.254264182 | 3.051305263 | 11.133 | 1.648 | 2.886148086 | 4.870084211 | 9.259 | 3.611 | 1.374509656 |
17 | 1.279326316 | 3.306 | 0 | 0.417743315 | 0.559515789 | 5.773 | 0 | 0.901017639 | 3.262431579 | 9.172 | 1.982 | 1.065415403 | 2.963989474 | 5.555 | 2.005 | 0.654151631 |
18 | 0.582505263 | 1.886 | 0 | 0.143924208 | 0.604073684 | 1.818 | 0 | 0.111574426 | 3.342736842 | 11.133 | 1.87 | 2.917561141 | 3.461084211 | 9.753 | 1.125 | 0.881864056 |
19 | 0.901 | 4.167 | 0 | 0.686005832 | 0.528884211 | 2.439 | 0 | 0.170148544 | 3.758852632 | 7.211 | 2.487 | 0.941864568 | 3.419684211 | 6.25 | 2.475 | 0.550954974 |
20 | 0.471821053 | 1.756 | 0 | 0.156592421 | 0.737126316 | 2.176 | 0 | 0.189872216 | 2.937747368 | 5.25 | 1.528 | 0.74350162 | 3.025568421 | 12.281 | 1.859 | 3.109390624 |
21 | 0.603431579 | 1.504 | 0 | 0.094120814 | 0.396810526 | 3.636 | 0 | 0.242635754 | 2.510263158 | 11.836 | 1.207 | 3.395018489 | 3.653326316 | 8.772 | 2.084 | 0.835635357 |
22 | 0.596578947 | 1.175 | 0 | 0.125514054 | 0.837073684 | 3.571 | 0 | 0.46596651 | 2.6558 | 8.792 | 0.865 | 1.694445192 | 2.755221053 | 5.264 | 1.792 | 0.290117499 |
23 | 0.9652 | 3.704 | 0 | 0.671732855 | 0.562694737 | 7.692 | 0 | 1.55875518 | 3.7862 | 9.389 | 2.1 | 2.205033802 | 3.849494737 | 11.999 | 1.653 | 1.955776313 |
24 | 0.831863158 | 4.051 | 0 | 0.415437781 | 1.595736842 | 3.356 | 0 | 0.438273731 | 1.498473684 | 9.091 | 0.2 | 3.112441512 | 2.718294737 | 13.723 | 1.667 | 3.366406334 |
25 | 0.570557895 | 3.391 | 0 | 0.648006541 | 0.425494737 | 4.478 | 0 | 0.597322629 | 1.739168421 | 5.455 | 0.377 | 0.714804203 | 3.075147368 | 6.826 | 1.686 | 0.600442757 |
26 | 0.580863158 | 4.388 | 0 | 0.656891508 | 0.762863158 | 4.474 | 0 | 0.435749108 | 2.152442105 | 4.76 | 1.189 | 0.312986878 | 3.306052632 | 10.791 | 1.215 | 1.238287376 |
27 | 1.263778947 | 6.963 | 0.095 | 1.060769646 | 0.384505263 | 6.169 | 0 | 0.791657534 | 1.208178947 | 4.616 | 0 | 0.468654926 | 2.441442105 | 8.578 | 1.216 | 0.879424205 |
28 | 1.687473684 | 2.89 | 0 | 0.513448439 | 0.577884211 | 8.527 | 0 | 2.15897545 | 1.173242105 | 3.448 | 0 | 0.383542394 | 3.943336842 | 8.064 | 2.439 | 0.607934287 |
29 | 0.731578947 | 3.633 | 0 | 0.328437191 | 0.544347368 | 5.391 | 0 | 0.542399364 | 1.120842105 | 7.018 | 0 | 1.111825101 | 3.501894737 | 14.286 | 1.907 | 2.915162389 |
30 | 1.244126316 | 5.328 | 0 | 0.594003731 | 0.758147368 | 7.936 | 0 | 1.797397199 | 1.487610526 | 8.621 | 0.26 | 1.719332448 | 3.210642105 | 14.286 | 1.625 | 3.143315156 |
31 | 0.683431579 | 8.196 | 0 | 1.582727887 | 1.180294737 | 12.698 | 0 | 3.902364018 | 2.1322 | 8.475 | 0.749 | 1.728003571 | 2.836821053 | 7.812 | 1.176 | 0.720062926 |
32 | 1.258768421 | 4.167 | 0 | 0.725367399 | 1.027021053 | 3.423 | 0 | 1.016975284 | 1.534968421 | 9.76 | 0.643 | 2.299645399 | 4.844115789 | 12.5 | 2.458 | 2.36816566 |
33 | 2.321926316 | 4.172 | 0 | 0.578747163 | 1.229589474 | 7.692 | 0 | 1.093361442 | 1.864263158 | 5.882 | 0.821 | 0.522960615 | 4.470610526 | 13.636 | 1.819 | 4.129724048 |
34 | 0.466789474 | 4.918 | 0 | 0.390507977 | 0.624210526 | 7.692 | 0 | 1.219461598 | 1.870757895 | 10.345 | 0 | 1.910724562 | 4.634336842 | 15.151 | 3.075 | 4.837536918 |
35 | 1.349589474 | 11.291 | 0 | 4.185881105 | 1.217894737 | 9.091 | 0 | 1.612704052 | 1.347347368 | 8.093 | 0 | 1.289222837 | 4.082557895 | 16.371 | 2.126 | 5.541035215 |
36 | 0.646515789 | 4.507 | 0 | 0.393450018 | 1.136873684 | 10.294 | 0 | 2.3590899 | 0.451578947 | 3.953 | 0 | 0.397298349 | 3.005568421 | 12.556 | 1.103 | 3.381670477 |
37 | 0.858694737 | 8.153 | 0 | 1.479102823 | 1.683042105 | 9.977 | 0 | 1.872427451 | 1.193442105 | 4.348 | 0 | 0.62549391 | 3.444821053 | 9.125 | 1.673 | 1.944790084 |
38 | 1.339694737 | 10.205 | 0 | 3.066392549 | 1.400789474 | 10.294 | 0 | 2.069335029 | 2.502210526 | 14.681 | 0.467 | 4.828091156 | 3.472568421 | 14.363 | 1.682 | 6.536721487 |
39 | 0.964231579 | 8.153 | 0 | 1.509837673 | 1.397968421 | 8.527 | 0 | 1.224982178 | 2.011073684 | 8.332 | 0.67 | 2.725403795 | 4.579621053 | 18.055 | 2.857 | 6.991261351 |
40 | 0.944263158 | 11.765 | 0 | 3.645862447 | 1.126715789 | 4.662 | 0 | 1.091607782 | 1.905094737 | 14.135 | 0.064 | 5.376184002 | 3.313747368 | 17.567 | 1.6 | 7.222622947 |
41 | 0.623073684 | 5.883 | 0 | 0.726308616 | 1.463410526 | 9.201 | 0 | 1.636111063 | 2.689052632 | 12.308 | 1.269 | 4.226300934 | 3.1354 | 8.22 | 0.433 | 1.937378577 |
42 | 1.624305263 | 12.857 | 0 | 6.116174991 | 1.105810526 | 11.606 | 0 | 3.472554406 | 0.533684211 | 3.048 | 0 | 0.321673984 | 2.938421053 | 15.069 | 0.878 | 6.021628581 |
43 | 0.802463158 | 8.824 | 0 | 2.221980964 | 2.370957895 | 4.583 | 0 | 0.918427514 | 1.930631579 | 10.769 | 0.803 | 2.675998801 | 3.270715789 | 14.458 | 0.791 | 7.208617635 |
44 | 3.703568421 | 20.29 | 1.01 | 15.60775425 | 1.684178947 | 7.097 | 0 | 0.807247747 | 0.754894737 | 6.061 | 0 | 0.917008305 | 4.1112 | 14.458 | 2.092 | 4.326992749 |
45 | 1.600357895 | 13.044 | 0 | 5.104870903 | 0.573621053 | 6.667 | 0 | 1.19543493 | 0.541863158 | 3.03 | 0 | 0.219453802 | 3.062652632 | 13.125 | 1.414 | 3.6734933 |
46 | 2.295252632 | 13.709 | 0.316 | 4.839829452 | 1.133536842 | 11.688 | 0 | 4.864747807 | 1.486252632 | 7.462 | 0 | 1.234800315 | 4.376052632 | 21.246 | 1.995 | 14.94259321 |
47 | 1.455610526 | 11.807 | 0 | 4.270879059 | 1.198715789 | 11.688 | 0 | 4.712201614 | 0.786589474 | 7.353 | 0 | 1.165708621 | 2.774452632 | 17.35 | 0.42 | 8.114272395 |
48 | 2.035347368 | 14.009 | 0.593 | 5.681389069 | 1.399589474 | 10.39 | 0 | 2.559840726 | 2.129315789 | 5.474 | 0.755 | 0.410714216 | 3.695126316 | 12.5 | 1.898 | 5.307067752 |
49 | 1.465947368 | 10.437 | 0.15 | 3.765985945 | 0.901989474 | 11.539 | 0 | 4.497321758 | 1.043326316 | 6.52 | 0 | 1.034811841 | 3.655315789 | 17.5 | 1.634 | 11.83795276 |
50 | 2.352852632 | 13.487 | 0.719 | 5.375030568 | 1.138389474 | 11.539 | 0 | 4.457905922 | 0.326136842 | 2.329 | 0 | 0.206708939 | 5.148631579 | 21.25 | 2.671 | 14.28049076 |
51 | 3.345494737 | 22.82 | 0.752 | 18.9807317 | 1.272652632 | 11.19 | 0 | 3.581417995 | 3.188978947 | 10.315 | 1.226 | 1.896858926 | 2.020694737 | 9.756 | 0 | 2.600074191 |
52 | 1.405452632 | 14.474 | 0 | 7.432012921 | 1.322115789 | 17.008 | 0 | 10.32702134 | 1.620389474 | 7.929 | 0 | 1.088246406 | 5.168610526 | 18.519 | 2.987 | 10.4463775 |
53 | 1.585231579 | 12.987 | 0 | 5.026952283 | 1.879957895 | 14.97 | 0 | 7.114846714 | 0.573863158 | 7.538 | 0 | 1.571601971 | 2.855557895 | 9.756 | 1.083 | 1.530628478 |
54 | 1.495536842 | 16.883 | 0 | 10.9158293 | 1.391421053 | 12.561 | 0 | 5.912029065 | 2.333978947 | 8.527 | 0.985 | 1.222208947 | 2.856515789 | 15.077 | 0.463 | 7.73437185 |
55 | 1.204136842 | 7.895 | 0.078 | 1.168496939 | 2.381957895 | 21.725 | 0 | 20.9657412 | 1.349536842 | 9.333 | 0 | 2.314367259 | 2.984178947 | 13.426 | 1.493 | 6.403251852 |
56 | 3.504084211 | 21.07 | 1.415 | 13.17303465 | 1.202894737 | 4.793 | 0 | 0.490927736 | 1.034515789 | 8 | 0 | 1.947421008 | 3.953378947 | 15.577 | 1.984 | 8.197556109 |
57 | 2.170631579 | 13.924 | 0.409 | 5.115410064 | 2.040873684 | 12.791 | 0 | 4.554928531 | 1.706284211 | 9.211 | 0.476 | 2.113594688 | 4.388852632 | 17.652 | 2.521 | 7.045510652 |
58 | 3.489410526 | 20.253 | 1.112 | 11.78249896 | 1.651063158 | 14.943 | 0 | 8.907458417 | 1.037905263 | 5.194 | 0 | 0.680744802 | 2.848136842 | 16.092 | 1.133 | 7.092554623 |
59 | 3.113421053 | 12.658 | 1.283 | 3.62004837 | 1.684652632 | 14.773 | 0 | 8.712219616 | 2.164968421 | 10.257 | 1.086 | 2.888747736 | 3.044768421 | 18.181 | 0.791 | 10.22278854 |
60 | 1.603336842 | 11.857 | 0 | 4.516401087 | 1.678 | 15.73 | 0 | 10.41611562 | 1.058242105 | 7.792 | 0.243 | 1.183817657 | 3.374484211 | 16.854 | 1.385 | 8.001123429 |
大致看来,vgg16和resnet20的效果说得过去,fashion和svhn的效果太差了,还是需要把四个模型仔细地对比一下。
依次为vgg16、resnet20、fashion、svhn的对比结果
1平均值 | 2平均值 | 3平均值 | 4平均值 | 1平均值 | 2平均值 | 3平均值 | 4平均值 | 1平均值 | 2平均值 | 3平均值 | 4平均值 | 1平均值 | 2平均值 | 3平均值 | 4平均值 | |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
5 | 1.737526316 | 30.32834737 | 6.683368421 | 0.740589474 | 2.692663158 | 24.2646 | 2.303221053 | 0.757515789 | 3.900715789 | 22.40829474 | 4.756894737 | 0.893010526 | 2.007010526 | 35.07458947 | 3.563347368 | 4.675210526 |
6 | 4.189747368 | 30.76668421 | 6.163442105 | 0.724378947 | 2.969178947 | 21.89826316 | 2.297663158 | 1.510484211 | 4.662652632 | 23.62644211 | 4.955663158 | 2.367473684 | 1.805168421 | 29.40378947 | 2.677947368 | 4.476252632 |
7 | 5.789252632 | 28.48361053 | 5.5608 | 0.751863158 | 1.447294737 | 17.58342105 | 3.569115789 | 0.777505263 | 3.352873684 | 21.20415789 | 5.742642105 | 0.530347368 | 2.762873684 | 19.83587368 | 3.427431579 | 4.159315789 |
8 | 5.859863158 | 27.88743158 | 3.736084211 | 0.567326316 | 1.529684211 | 14.7254 | 3.323431579 | 0.365147368 | 2.547694737 | 12.21869474 | 4.233947368 | 1.6382 | 3.408673684 | 25.10787368 | 3.770557895 | 4.277936842 |
9 | 5.009968421 | 24.31814737 | 5.027915789 | 0.793052632 | 1.508242105 | 13.11305263 | 3.485694737 | 1.068884211 | 3.765326316 | 12.20282105 | 4.421252632 | 0.558578947 | 2.653452632 | 16.46205263 | 4.027578947 | 4.570968421 |
10 | 6.356421053 | 14.14335789 | 5.337536842 | 2.718768421 | 3.923778947 | 8.922736842 | 4.335168421 | 0.544252632 | 3.046410526 | 6.226263158 | 4.771326316 | 1.945378947 | 2.474663158 | 17.97963158 | 4.059178947 | 5.201989474 |
11 | 6.057315789 | 16.32817895 | 5.871821053 | 2.793010526 | 3.530357895 | 7.802610526 | 3.707547368 | 0.695915789 | 2.801115789 | 7.155768421 | 4.636568421 | 1.815684211 | 2.242715789 | 15.45973684 | 3.569936842 | 4.685252632 |
12 | 6.218821053 | 16.31132632 | 5.345526316 | 2.270621053 | 3.224494737 | 6.014842105 | 3.095978947 | 1.464894737 | 2.799905263 | 7.671263158 | 5.730115789 | 1.968894737 | 2.511894737 | 14.0708 | 5.271547368 | 3.598515789 |
13 | 5.7838 | 13.86188421 | 4.410221053 | 3.096010526 | 3.240789474 | 3.834978947 | 2.931031579 | 2.418515789 | 2.707357895 | 6.507915789 | 5.778757895 | 1.338231579 | 2.393873684 | 13.87044211 | 3.696652632 | 4.483852632 |
14 | 5.292389474 | 14.29063158 | 3.850684211 | 1.009368421 | 2.952778947 | 3.067263158 | 3.205431579 | 1.803557895 | 2.047084211 | 4.342178947 | 5.485305263 | 2.258936842 | 2.349326316 | 14.23810526 | 4.001842105 | 2.026631579 |
15 | 5.482852632 | 13.43101053 | 4.703505263 | 0.763252632 | 2.970463158 | 2.731947368 | 2.468936842 | 1.459736842 | 2.516852632 | 2.436115789 | 5.313821053 | 2.430084211 | 2.1884 | 16.89207368 | 3.825 | 2.027284211 |
16 | 5.5298 | 14.47966316 | 3.106905263 | 0.674884211 | 2.731684211 | 2.772421053 | 2.535873684 | 0.873168421 | 2.184705263 | 1.912936842 | 5.221715789 | 3.051305263 | 2.189557895 | 12.15753684 | 4.178305263 | 4.870084211 |
17 | 5.869157895 | 12.65016842 | 3.913926316 | 1.279326316 | 2.544673684 | 3.829368421 | 2.005621053 | 0.559515789 | 2.174873684 | 1.121231579 | 5.809284211 | 3.262431579 | 2.055431579 | 13.62584211 | 5.003884211 | 2.963989474 |
18 | 5.306147368 | 12.90841053 | 2.935578947 | 0.582505263 | 2.403978947 | 3.679021053 | 2.507684211 | 0.604073684 | 1.953494737 | 1.303168421 | 5.946357895 | 3.342736842 | 2.013168421 | 10.79661053 | 3.578073684 | 3.461084211 |
19 | 5.602610526 | 12.41743158 | 3.186021053 | 0.901 | 2.408873684 | 4.102336842 | 2.095821053 | 0.528884211 | 1.969442105 | 3.340263158 | 5.201010526 | 3.758852632 | 1.993431579 | 11.34854737 | 5.005063158 | 3.419684211 |
20 | 5.936473684 | 14.34192632 | 2.028705263 | 0.471821053 | 2.416663158 | 4.083873684 | 2.543263158 | 0.737126316 | 2.077442105 | 1.675852632 | 5.185115789 | 2.937747368 | 2.061147368 | 12.7972 | 3.588589474 | 3.025568421 |
21 | 5.360273684 | 14.66232632 | 2.850347368 | 0.603431579 | 2.4206 | 5.205652632 | 2.805042105 | 0.396810526 | 2.044031579 | 2.749452632 | 5.219336842 | 2.510263158 | 2.044557895 | 12.03156842 | 4.811242105 | 3.653326316 |
22 | 5.3314 | 14.146 | 2.703242105 | 0.596578947 | 2.26 | 4.212852632 | 1.690168421 | 0.837073684 | 1.954357895 | 2.049694737 | 5.626168421 | 2.6558 | 2.095284211 | 15.50416842 | 5.717652632 | 2.755221053 |
23 | 4.845642105 | 13.80082105 | 1.960821053 | 0.9652 | 2.213589474 | 3.986557895 | 2.344442105 | 0.562694737 | 2.025368421 | 1.900778947 | 3.932431579 | 3.7862 | 1.999821053 | 13.10349474 | 4.421273684 | 3.849494737 |
24 | 5.153494737 | 14.86201053 | 3.696968421 | 0.831863158 | 2.261463158 | 3.159042105 | 2.643884211 | 1.595736842 | 1.835463158 | 2.800884211 | 6.037147368 | 1.498473684 | 2.034221053 | 11.84731579 | 5.079705263 | 2.718294737 |
25 | 4.956610526 | 12.80029474 | 4.008326316 | 0.570557895 | 2.126863158 | 2.682621053 | 3.363315789 | 0.425494737 | 2.063736842 | 2.900326316 | 5.407231579 | 1.739168421 | 2.030673684 | 9.841905263 | 5.514442105 | 3.075147368 |
26 | 4.854505263 | 10.64034737 | 2.944526316 | 0.580863158 | 2.178757895 | 2.185378947 | 2.916768421 | 0.762863158 | 2.002547368 | 2.671242105 | 3.962136842 | 2.152442105 | 1.961115789 | 10.23884211 | 5.624557895 | 3.306052632 |
27 | 4.986789474 | 11.67094737 | 3.303505263 | 1.263778947 | 2.171210526 | 2.596231579 | 2.197757895 | 0.384505263 | 2.029715789 | 1.358736842 | 5.292484211 | 1.208178947 | 2.072852632 | 3.919389474 | 4.948557895 | 2.441442105 |
28 | 4.509947368 | 10.00345263 | 3.682252632 | 1.687473684 | 2.109936842 | 2.583126316 | 3.335831579 | 0.577884211 | 1.924336842 | 2.723326316 | 3.834568421 | 1.173242105 | 2.030863158 | 5.629884211 | 6.035705263 | 3.943336842 |
29 | 4.805347368 | 10.30368421 | 2.488926316 | 0.731578947 | 2.031136842 | 3.180052632 | 2.326042105 | 0.544347368 | 1.949926316 | 2.568136842 | 3.926284211 | 1.120842105 | 1.930936842 | 4.561094737 | 4.101105263 | 3.501894737 |
30 | 4.330894737 | 10.46677895 | 2.917389474 | 1.244126316 | 2.003210526 | 2.7014 | 2.507947368 | 0.758147368 | 1.797021053 | 2.843105263 | 3.184936842 | 1.487610526 | 1.932631579 | 4.061936842 | 4.677663158 | 3.210642105 |
31 | 4.334284211 | 11.42287368 | 1.841410526 | 0.683431579 | 1.9958 | 3.946305263 | 2.607831579 | 1.180294737 | 1.823368421 | 1.664663158 | 3.903978947 | 2.1322 | 1.936989474 | 5.071757895 | 5.402094737 | 2.836821053 |
32 | 4.482610526 | 10.56034737 | 3.115736842 | 1.258768421 | 1.982252632 | 2.874031579 | 2.903778947 | 1.027021053 | 1.810947368 | 2.7178 | 3.608852632 | 1.534968421 | 2.048442105 | 4.397568421 | 5.328084211 | 4.844115789 |
33 | 4.242147368 | 11.37886316 | 2.812242105 | 2.321926316 | 1.995863158 | 3.625315789 | 3.521589474 | 1.229589474 | 2.035947368 | 2.508073684 | 2.343957895 | 1.864263158 | 2.251178947 | 5.243831579 | 5.699631579 | 4.470610526 |
34 | 3.8434 | 9.436021053 | 3.478126316 | 0.466789474 | 1.979031579 | 2.664252632 | 3.496968421 | 0.624210526 | 1.702621053 | 2.620157895 | 4.853410526 | 1.870757895 | 2.177315789 | 4.955326316 | 5.788294737 | 4.634336842 |
35 | 3.953010526 | 10.70486316 | 2.753368421 | 1.349589474 | 2.025252632 | 3.622305263 | 2.687231579 | 1.217894737 | 1.906021053 | 2.855968421 | 3.561421053 | 1.347347368 | 2.130031579 | 5.379726316 | 4.2988 | 4.082557895 |
36 | 4.149442105 | 8.565357895 | 2.3654 | 0.646515789 | 2.096821053 | 3.182694737 | 3.375673684 | 1.136873684 | 1.820431579 | 1.709684211 | 3.276421053 | 0.451578947 | 2.254 | 4.577757895 | 5.492157895 | 3.005568421 |
37 | 4.288242105 | 8.971652632 | 3.2604 | 0.858694737 | 2.152736842 | 3.435221053 | 3.3106 | 1.683042105 | 1.998189474 | 1.648305263 | 3.214294737 | 1.193442105 | 2.149557895 | 3.552042105 | 4.755178947 | 3.444821053 |
38 | 3.990568421 | 8.872736842 | 3.681736842 | 1.339694737 | 2.132357895 | 3.594084211 | 2.297221053 | 1.400789474 | 2.033126316 | 2.037252632 | 3.811431579 | 2.502210526 | 1.939736842 | 3.522084211 | 4.996989474 | 3.472568421 |
39 | 4.052821053 | 10.99558947 | 1.812221053 | 0.964231579 | 2.363536842 | 2.848515789 | 2.733526316 | 1.397968421 | 1.920821053 | 3.171442105 | 3.204410526 | 2.011073684 | 2.671515789 | 2.086747368 | 4.450810526 | 4.579621053 |
40 | 4.188284211 | 6.197347368 | 1.893926316 | 0.944263158 | 2.479557895 | 2.996705263 | 2.927021053 | 1.126715789 | 1.790652632 | 2.518442105 | 2.882884211 | 1.905094737 | 1.904273684 | 3.586915789 | 4.858894737 | 3.313747368 |
41 | 4.153031579 | 9.258094737 | 2.350105263 | 0.623073684 | 2.313631579 | 3.526789474 | 3.252263158 | 1.463410526 | 2.059210526 | 3.298021053 | 2.781031579 | 2.689052632 | 2.764063158 | 4.078210526 | 5.578821053 | 3.1354 |
42 | 3.478526316 | 9.580189474 | 3.7246 | 1.624305263 | 2.737926316 | 3.274084211 | 2.762168421 | 1.105810526 | 1.771915789 | 2.276863158 | 3.257084211 | 0.533684211 | 2.535 | 5.766273684 | 5.4672 | 2.938421053 |
43 | 3.417378947 | 6.382305263 | 2.879105263 | 0.802463158 | 2.700168421 | 3.640052632 | 2.557778947 | 2.370957895 | 1.991557895 | 3.228768421 | 3.832978947 | 1.930631579 | 2.744263158 | 2.930557895 | 4.844052632 | 3.270715789 |
44 | 3.626168421 | 6.006884211 | 2.164957895 | 3.703568421 | 2.512294737 | 3.800557895 | 2.663063158 | 1.684178947 | 2.363926316 | 4.312294737 | 3.886157895 | 0.754894737 | 2.579368421 | 3.538684211 | 4.648073684 | 4.1112 |
45 | 3.849421053 | 5.206894737 | 2.752031579 | 1.600357895 | 2.810831579 | 3.557515789 | 2.913136842 | 0.573621053 | 1.985789474 | 3.623010526 | 3.308578947 | 0.541863158 | 2.359 | 3.446557895 | 5.330157895 | 3.062652632 |
46 | 3.3 | 6.124010526 | 2.761768421 | 2.295252632 | 2.778842105 | 3.714421053 | 2.764178947 | 1.133536842 | 1.863284211 | 3.567610526 | 2.523778947 | 1.486252632 | 2.963673684 | 3.975936842 | 5.115315789 | 4.376052632 |
47 | 3.447926316 | 5.451852632 | 2.528210526 | 1.455610526 | 2.582115789 | 4.761242105 | 2.656284211 | 1.198715789 | 2.196736842 | 4.246189474 | 3.267063158 | 0.786589474 | 2.553368421 | 3.802010526 | 5.477557895 | 2.774452632 |
48 | 4.031484211 | 5.592157895 | 2.104231579 | 2.035347368 | 3.030757895 | 3.442978947 | 2.766 | 1.399589474 | 2.295536842 | 2.230547368 | 3.225347368 | 2.129315789 | 2.753442105 | 3.447621053 | 4.042326316 | 3.695126316 |
49 | 3.626294737 | 5.974105263 | 2.559989474 | 1.465947368 | 2.86 | 3.406084211 | 2.547326316 | 0.901989474 | 1.838747368 | 2.243568421 | 3.667178947 | 1.043326316 | 2.9844 | 3.102189474 | 4.163168421 | 3.655315789 |
50 | 2.980610526 | 5.868094737 | 2.8328 | 2.352852632 | 3.002357895 | 3.393147368 | 2.618294737 | 1.138389474 | 2.077589474 | 3.353631579 | 4.033421053 | 0.326136842 | 3.049389474 | 3.046884211 | 3.951936842 | 5.148631579 |
51 | 3.432389474 | 6.001557895 | 1.984252632 | 3.345494737 | 2.809621053 | 3.961178947 | 2.425136842 | 1.272652632 | 2.133147368 | 2.726926316 | 3.202884211 | 3.188978947 | 3.284494737 | 2.744452632 | 5.176768421 | 2.020694737 |
52 | 3.413557895 | 5.709863158 | 2.883715789 | 1.405452632 | 2.957978947 | 4.144347368 | 2.507494737 | 1.322115789 | 2.557105263 | 3.390631579 | 3.571378947 | 1.620389474 | 2.582842105 | 4.122073684 | 4.921073684 | 5.168610526 |
53 | 3.617884211 | 4.617642105 | 2.577357895 | 1.585231579 | 3.450273684 | 3.877315789 | 2.486610526 | 1.879957895 | 2.417663158 | 2.831705263 | 3.5886 | 0.573863158 | 3.412978947 | 3.399852632 | 5.048778947 | 2.855557895 |
54 | 3.545452632 | 6.564705263 | 2.477136842 | 1.495536842 | 3.242557895 | 4.4762 | 2.839663158 | 1.391421053 | 2.508842105 | 2.983842105 | 2.946126316 | 2.333978947 | 2.261663158 | 5.385073684 | 4.350473684 | 2.856515789 |
55 | 3.385105263 | 6.658263158 | 2.487052632 | 1.204136842 | 3.382305263 | 4.410421053 | 2.439757895 | 2.381957895 | 2.1818 | 2.957915789 | 2.779284211 | 1.349536842 | 2.9274 | 3.210936842 | 4.612347368 | 2.984178947 |
56 | 3.280589474 | 5.887736842 | 2.875884211 | 3.504084211 | 3.166947368 | 4.782326316 | 2.042021053 | 1.202894737 | 2.506252632 | 2.485852632 | 2.529042105 | 1.034515789 | 3.273084211 | 4.170547368 | 4.473621053 | 3.953378947 |
57 | 3.549178947 | 6.290115789 | 2.836189474 | 2.170631579 | 3.276694737 | 4.570336842 | 3.056978947 | 2.040873684 | 2.752157895 | 2.616631579 | 2.957873684 | 1.706284211 | 3.003526316 | 5.293957895 | 4.759894737 | 4.388852632 |
58 | 3.295052632 | 7.274042105 | 3.731157895 | 3.489410526 | 3.094978947 | 4.145336842 | 3.187789474 | 1.651063158 | 2.874778947 | 4.257147368 | 4.260326316 | 1.037905263 | 3.887042105 | 5.183010526 | 4.592905263 | 2.848136842 |
59 | 3.040431579 | 5.953305263 | 3.232484211 | 3.113421053 | 3.2148 | 4.057989474 | 3.417789474 | 1.684652632 | 2.948115789 | 2.860021053 | 3.200273684 | 2.164968421 | 3.1278 | 2.577736842 | 4.773126316 | 3.044768421 |
60 | 3.271252632 | 5.658021053 | 3.139705263 | 1.603336842 | 3.414252632 | 4.221136842 | 2.973042105 | 1.678 | 2.921042105 | 3.630736842 | 3.0182 | 1.058242105 | 3.666305263 | 4.734621053 | 4.386094737 | 3.374484211 |
可以看到在vgg16和resnet20上case4的优势比较大,因此最优的效果还可以接受,但是对于fashion和svhn,反而case1比较占优势,onehot_refine_200_2000降维后效果相较于不降维有了一定幅度的提升,但是还是没有达到理想的效果。因为使用的SVD降维没有考虑奇异值选取问题,只要降维统一设的参数都是降维至100,之前尝至500的时候效果也是不理想,接下来再做一组对比实验,看这四种情况在降至其他维度时效果会不会有改善,希望能从中找到确定最终维度的方法。
奇异值平方和 | 前100奇异值平方和 | 百分比 | |
---|---|---|---|
mnist_lenet1 | 699439.9999999998 | 599112.1679507367 | 85.66 |
mnist_lenet4 | 801220.7584010088 | 742486.7844289693 | 92.67 |
mnist_lenet5 | 865064.9999999998 | 647324.7025369342 | 74.83 |
cifar10_vgg16 | 1200351.0 | 764782.2132995642 | 61.71 |
cifar10_resnet20 | 1104252.0 | 729830.2404693662 | 66.09 |
svhn_lenet5 | 1812669.0 | 1253828.6798741636 | 69.17 |
fashion_lenet5 | 579356.9999999998 | 412068.1597127195 | 71.13 |
就这个结果看,初步猜想可能是这四种情况下降维幅度较大,接下来针对这四个模型分别降维至平方和的80%、90%、95%观察效果有无改善。
1平均值 | 2平均值 | 3平均值 | 1平均值 | 2平均值 | 3平均值 | 1平均值 | 2平均值 | 3平均值 | 1平均值 | 2平均值 | 3平均值 | ||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
5 | 0.581410526 | 0.765789474 | 0.798168421 | 0.798168421 | 0.782715789 | 0.787473684 | 0.865 | 0.817336842 | 0.816694737 | 4.213347368 | 3.758410526 | 3.9042 | |||
6 | 0.538810526 | 0.461473684 | 0.445210526 | 1.577094737 | 1.602505263 | 1.606842105 | 2.374484211 | 2.345189474 | 2.329378947 | 4.229368421 | 4.434505263 | 4.513536842 | |||
7 | 0.649778947 | 0.615168421 | 0.620421053 | 0.768242105 | 0.807052632 | 0.808336842 | 0.524136842 | 0.573368421 | 0.565905263 | 3.671389474 | 2.075389474 | 2.124905263 | |||
8 | 0.597884211 | 0.678578947 | 0.668147368 | 0.358094737 | 0.395284211 | 0.396968421 | 1.495526316 | 1.414305263 | 1.3516 | 2.723536842 | 2.906263158 | 2.887989474 | |||
9 | 1.100631579 | 1.108694737 | 1.208368421 | 1.090284211 | 1.091705263 | 1.107547368 | 0.772578947 | 1.095273684 | 1.093326316 | 3.188789474 | 3.653789474 | 3.428368421 | |||
10 | 2.963536842 | 3.077105263 | 3.197115789 | 0.550536842 | 0.424715789 | 0.438305263 | 0.775042105 | 0.968484211 | 1.849094737 | 4.3928 | 4.513315789 | 4.277831579 | |||
11 | 2.276631579 | 2.811768421 | 2.835915789 | 0.542905263 | 0.691852632 | 0.686326316 | 0.434442105 | 1.758547368 | 0.453831579 | 3.241189474 | 4.269431579 | 3.396568421 | |||
12 | 2.455484211 | 2.540094737 | 2.475357895 | 1.195115789 | 1.617221053 | 1.687463158 | 1.872884211 | 1.395473684 | 1.457484211 | 2.858221053 | 2.933894737 | 3.436378947 | |||
13 | 0.371968421 | 3.154684211 | 3.195936842 | 1.269305263 | 2.295178947 | 2.401326316 | 1.187115789 | 1.383705263 | 1.396221053 | 3.698757895 | 4.532705263 | 4.384063158 | |||
14 | 0.958368421 | 1.412631579 | 1.285905263 | 2.044905263 | 1.009473684 | 0.958221053 | 2.492494737 | 1.776694737 | 1.760031579 | 2.664473684 | 4.157989474 | 4.718357895 | |||
15 | 1.579715789 | 1.7544 | 1.494642105 | 1.388126316 | 2.636957895 | 2.697831579 | 2.971094737 | 2.744326316 | 2.758473684 | 5.176263158 | 4.4612 | 2.134978947 | |||
16 | 1.969705263 | 2.372442105 | 1.928347368 | 1.259126316 | 1.434747368 | 0.521221053 | 2.563189474 | 3.615210526 | 3.693378947 | 1.944842105 | 2.499905263 | 4.276010526 | |||
17 | 0.886589474 | 0.501715789 | 0.519526316 | 1.922284211 | 1.911894737 | 0.487073684 | 2.736221053 | 2.262242105 | 2.261126316 | 2.439652632 | 1.429821053 | 2.5352 | |||
18 | 0.880989474 | 1.170652632 | 1.320210526 | 1.068368421 | 0.767484211 | 1.288410526 | 3.023157895 | 1.993105263 | 2.569568421 | 2.294547368 | 4.085136842 | 4.476894737 | |||
19 | 1.646347368 | 1.082421053 | 2.077610526 | 1.229494737 | 0.601252632 | 0.616505263 | 3.330536842 | 1.563421053 | 2.073578947 | 2.083126316 | 2.597063158 | 1.745315789 | |||
20 | 0.819842105 | 0.468968421 | 0.729115789 | 1.183631579 | 0.829694737 | 0.792642105 | 3.086768421 | 3.391305263 | 2.705557895 | 1.940294737 | 1.515768421 | 2.111452632 | |||
21 | 0.777494737 | 0.621884211 | 0.866168421 | 0.316063158 | 0.617526316 | 0.590021053 | 3.116210526 | 1.130915789 | 2.248147368 | 2.408157895 | 5.491852632 | 3.5086 | |||
22 | 1.547968421 | 1.406315789 | 1.363368421 | 0.309810526 | 0.521368421 | 0.4888 | 2.605178947 | 2.992094737 | 2.977926316 | 3.1366 | 2.537715789 | 2.679294737 | |||
23 | 0.323515789 | 1.7448 | 0.576831579 | 0.782178947 | 0.851673684 | 0.370157895 | 0.832821053 | 1.208747368 | 1.463484211 | 3.2494 | 2.437210526 | 2.221842105 | |||
24 | 1.398389474 | 0.725663158 | 0.631705263 | 0.852052632 | 1.009421053 | 1.198631579 | 2.020536842 | 1.549105263 | 2.400873684 | 2.308589474 | 2.778168421 | 2.662231579 | |||
25 | 0.285221053 | 0.740115789 | 1.085084211 | 0.749326316 | 1.337210526 | 0.7008 | 3.385915789 | 2.143021053 | 2.125063158 | 3.343515789 | 3.095252632 | 3.099242105 | |||
26 | 0.712063158 | 0.435526316 | 1.072884211 | 0.447157895 | 1.003768421 | 0.612589474 | 2.567157895 | 2.078252632 | 2.927273684 | 2.407147368 | 2.235063158 | 2.667536842 | |||
27 | 0.714684211 | 0.858263158 | 1.439336842 | 0.479915789 | 1.180221053 | 0.971673684 | 1.472631579 | 3.523210526 | 1.691673684 | 2.472705263 | 1.978894737 | 3.334073684 | |||
28 | 0.449863158 | 0.705115789 | 1.244084211 | 1.539557895 | 1.554663158 | 2.027726316 | 1.211347368 | 1.552378947 | 0.992484211 | 2.469221053 | 3.220589474 | 3.110526316 | |||
29 | 0.930873684 | 0.869842105 | 0.906715789 | 0.978115789 | 0.924252632 | 1.164431579 | 2.199778947 | 1.803663158 | 2.687631579 | 3.121031579 | 4.930778947 | 4.014421053 | |||
30 | 0.883684211 | 0.900052632 | 0.874147368 | 0.576378947 | 1.723863158 | 1.723894737 | 1.368842105 | 1.7424 | 1.769368421 | 3.416021053 | 4.263126316 | 3.293852632 | |||
31 | 1.058389474 | 1.632421053 | 0.819368421 | 1.140210526 | 1.307747368 | 1.230052632 | 2.068305263 | 2.270663158 | 1.498210526 | 2.166463158 | 5.091115789 | 0.877884211 | |||
32 | 0.485378947 | 1.135115789 | 0.639063158 | 0.572284211 | 0.466631579 | 0.523884211 | 1.404010526 | 3.320473684 | 2.561084211 | 5.146757895 | 4.966168421 | 4.222863158 | |||
33 | 1.053705263 | 1.489252632 | 1.587810526 | 1.934463158 | 1.279968421 | 0.689273684 | 1.895389474 | 1.601957895 | 2.7256 | 2.202168421 | 5.163852632 | 2.945347368 | |||
34 | 0.6382 | 0.878842105 | 1.686073684 | 1.7054 | 0.753957895 | 1.622431579 | 1.152694737 | 1.565947368 | 1.723242105 | 4.167663158 | 1.901978947 | 2.546484211 | |||
35 | 0.863273684 | 0.895210526 | 0.471084211 | 0.905389474 | 1.668157895 | 0.652273684 | 0.607242105 | 2.124715789 | 1.430957895 | 5.074010526 | 3.820715789 | 3.977578947 | |||
36 | 0.938610526 | 0.985105263 | 1.439452632 | 0.902210526 | 0.814326316 | 0.501463158 | 2.015757895 | 1.760126316 | 1.584336842 | 3.431694737 | 2.313336842 | 5.785252632 | |||
37 | 0.964663158 | 0.446684211 | 1.760231579 | 1.520673684 | 1.4676 | 1.147915789 | 0.731768421 | 2.866210526 | 1.060168421 | 1.766115789 | 4.419789474 | 1.878073684 | |||
38 | 1.495326316 | 1.730273684 | 0.744410526 | 1.009884211 | 0.574810526 | 1.119642105 | 1.341842105 | 2.319147368 | 2.289052632 | 3.388905263 | 4.335252632 | 2.787284211 | |||
39 | 0.544368421 | 0.857526316 | 0.601221053 | 1.141989474 | 1.205326316 | 1.026473684 | 0.961557895 | 1.361536842 | 1.7502 | 4.457705263 | 4.337936842 | 4.168947368 | |||
40 | 0.903242105 | 1.528621053 | 0.729452632 | 1.701263158 | 0.968631579 | 1.343368421 | 0.671821053 | 1.1462 | 2.411684211 | 4.284968421 | 1.921294737 | 4.245578947 | |||
41 | 1.140347368 | 1.272705263 | 0.911221053 | 1.409642105 | 1.573757895 | 1.8434 | 1.423136842 | 0.7222 | 0.970305263 | 6.0804 | 3.532989474 | 3.234178947 | |||
42 | 1.479178947 | 1.591694737 | 1.047821053 | 0.828831579 | 0.554094737 | 1.259105263 | 1.686231579 | 1.139421053 | 1.480273684 | 2.719547368 | 1.770336842 | 4.226884211 | |||
43 | 1.367547368 | 1.056736842 | 1.096968421 | 0.842705263 | 1.173431579 | 1.162136842 | 0.809863158 | 0.597936842 | 0.6948 | 5.089578947 | 4.069084211 | 2.959810526 | |||
44 | 2.629431579 | 1.026789474 | 0.730652632 | 0.562863158 | 1.963526316 | 1.227705263 | 1.114389474 | 0.672084211 | 0.843042105 | 4.000010526 | 1.609526316 | 3.419705263 | |||
45 | 0.523315789 | 0.757505263 | 0.879915789 | 1.748789474 | 1.252884211 | 0.969 | 1.468673684 | 0.888926316 | 1.284136842 | 4.845673684 | 5.940326316 | 2.905484211 | |||
46 | 1.209947368 | 1.110231579 | 1.583263158 | 1.575252632 | 0.977684211 | 1.730747368 | 2.137210526 | 2.425578947 | 0.519768421 | 6.808621053 | 4.186694737 | 1.323042105 | |||
47 | 2.654673684 | 1.262821053 | 0.955368421 | 1.171684211 | 1.3392 | 0.828989474 | 1.343073684 | 0.961684211 | 1.953915789 | 6.097957895 | 2.207715789 | 4.315305263 | |||
48 | 1.576810526 | 1.524768421 | 2.517326316 | 1.144631579 | 1.010747368 | 2.1258 | 0.575231579 | 0.592073684 | 0.637315789 | 2.703915789 | 3.806347368 | 4.070357895 | |||
49 | 1.757231579 | 0.896189474 | 2.199410526 | 1.276663158 | 1.644378947 | 1.147284211 | 0.479873684 | 2.827831579 | 1.7286 | 4.794421053 | 3.399863158 | 2.744284211 | |||
50 | 0.915726316 | 0.808242105 | 1.509926316 | 1.410536842 | 1.781589474 | 2.529831579 | 0.550178947 | 1.971084211 | 0.525210526 | 3.303431579 | 5.468168421 | 4.068831579 | |||
51 | 1.090789474 | 0.861589474 | 1.3676 | 0.967347368 | 1.497305263 | 1.365042105 | 0.688757895 | 0.944757895 | 1.226915789 | 2.861063158 | 5.795947368 | 5.300547368 | |||
52 | 1.332136842 | 1.951568421 | 2.812105263 | 1.405652632 | 1.178031579 | 1.093715789 | 1.334305263 | 0.876431579 | 0.831 | 4.971210526 | 2.457810526 | 3.100105263 | |||
53 | 1.041621053 | 1.016473684 | 1.154736842 | 1.415031579 | 1.498178947 | 1.509326316 | 0.6426 | 1.198789474 | 1.447926316 | 3.904547368 | 5.661294737 | 2.155273684 | |||
54 | 1.655031579 | 2.237789474 | 0.899821053 | 1.8372 | 0.792263158 | 1.417557895 | 0.805726316 | 0.844842105 | 1.172042105 | 4.356252632 | 3.486536842 | 2.249568421 | |||
55 | 1.634178947 | 0.628684211 | 1.262126316 | 1.294357895 | 1.130547368 | 1.9228 | 0.716789474 | 1.391315789 | 1.085252632 | 2.466547368 | 2.896505263 | 4.441136842 | |||
56 | 2.066052632 | 1.839515789 | 1.577505263 | 2.058378947 | 1.337115789 | 1.963947368 | 2.071715789 | 2.439968421 | 0.849905263 | 4.067221053 | 5.374126316 | 3.669157895 | |||
57 | 3.153905263 | 0.652431579 | 0.821063158 | 1.251810526 | 1.234021053 | 1.588357895 | 0.896684211 | 1.678378947 | 0.344294737 | 4.495526316 | 5.831831579 | 3.873957895 | |||
58 | 3.010778947 | 1.428578947 | 1.692147368 | 2.269705263 | 1.656631579 | 0.9258 | 1.756221053 | 0.889031579 | 0.443294737 | 3.809778947 | 3.233326316 | 3.615526316 | |||
59 | 1.084010526 | 3.056421053 | 1.859136842 | 1.584273684 | 1.210915789 | 1.777578947 | 0.551989474 | 1.308926316 | 1.165652632 | 4.483252632 | 5.103389474 | 5.187821053 | |||
60 | 1.882694737 | 1.694684211 | 2.308347368 | 1.365263158 | 2.714042105 | 0.925589474 | 1.181357895 | 0.569568421 | 1.002421053 | 3.628547368 | 4.788831579 | 5.609505263 |
依这个结果来看,似乎降维的幅度对效果的影响不是很大,降至80% 90% 95%的情况里很难说有哪一种是有很明显的优势,在mnist_lenet145上也是一样。
1平均值 | 2平均值 | 3平均值 | 1平均值 | 2平均值 | 3平均值 | 1平均值 | 2平均值 | 3平均值 | |||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
5 | 1.004494737 | 1.034136842 | 1.033947368 | 0.553105263 | 0.531021053 | 0.531715789 | 0.764915789 | 0.764915789 | 0.768031579 | ||
6 | 0.718273684 | 0.706694737 | 0.741747368 | 0.746231579 | 0.7366 | 0.738452632 | 0.744894737 | 0.749326316 | 0.749326316 | ||
7 | 1.216631579 | 1.198821053 | 0.692526316 | 0.539947368 | 0.330347368 | 0.323126316 | 0.377010526 | 0.385505263 | 0.418494737 | ||
8 | 0.912431579 | 0.450568421 | 0.810368421 | 0.443052632 | 0.194231579 | 0.194231579 | 0.382073684 | 0.614915789 | 0.271294737 | ||
9 | 0.402894737 | 1.158221053 | 0.535705263 | 0.626652632 | 0.636410526 | 0.634610526 | 0.524978947 | 0.527242105 | 0.544042105 | ||
10 | 0.711315789 | 0.801852632 | 0.856494737 | 0.651852632 | 0.654768421 | 0.698168421 | 0.572410526 | 0.5318 | 0.5318 | ||
11 | 0.505578947 | 0.850431579 | 0.448705263 | 0.342968421 | 0.356568421 | 0.186831579 | 0.357905263 | 0.469705263 | 0.475905263 | ||
12 | 0.506105263 | 1.001715789 | 0.451115789 | 0.257705263 | 0.292978947 | 0.290231579 | 0.356621053 | 0.179768421 | 0.468105263 | ||
13 | 0.463873684 | 0.532326316 | 0.719978947 | 0.151378947 | 0.210568421 | 0.254989474 | 0.455652632 | 0.506821053 | 0.213926316 | ||
14 | 0.548294737 | 0.444978947 | 0.5178 | 0.418305263 | 0.207378947 | 0.547705263 | 0.275378947 | 0.174494737 | 0.1446 | ||
15 | 0.4016 | 0.318305263 | 0.4584 | 0.463894737 | 0.694378947 | 0.598905263 | 0.470715789 | 0.359431579 | 0.426873684 | ||
16 | 0.347831579 | 0.793136842 | 0.361705263 | 0.255663158 | 0.654168421 | 0.274610526 | 0.181684211 | 0.411978947 | 0.345294737 | ||
17 | 0.750484211 | 0.891557895 | 0.662873684 | 1.017357895 | 0.461610526 | 0.188242105 | 0.432178947 | 0.341452632 | 0.345989474 | ||
18 | 0.5592 | 0.572663158 | 0.434284211 | 0.677526316 | 0.368936842 | 0.555305263 | 0.284410526 | 0.244821053 | 0.455789474 | ||
19 | 0.357010526 | 0.717463158 | 0.830105263 | 0.559 | 0.225568421 | 0.424326316 | 0.373778947 | 0.373210526 | 0.440915789 | ||
20 | 1.204894737 | 0.293294737 | 0.999894737 | 0.8736 | 0.201305263 | 0.344726316 | 0.115610526 | 0.4756 | 0.437136842 | ||
21 | 0.2876 | 0.2532 | 0.344442105 | 0.611273684 | 0.764063158 | 0.754178947 | 0.431063158 | 0.513147368 | 0.181094737 | ||
22 | 0.411778947 | 0.591021053 | 0.529115789 | 0.648894737 | 0.810726316 | 0.410673684 | 0.274947368 | 0.501757895 | 0.657442105 | ||
23 | 0.281315789 | 0.937842105 | 0.261915789 | 0.792789474 | 0.830031579 | 0.647263158 | 0.546831579 | 0.487105263 | 0.415031579 | ||
24 | 0.550631579 | 0.912652632 | 0.858894737 | 1.053389474 | 0.572621053 | 0.124884211 | 0.476789474 | 0.314968421 | 0.474589474 | ||
25 | 0.598052632 | 0.323842105 | 0.327284211 | 0.620852632 | 0.352926316 | 0.527547368 | 0.377273684 | 0.637978947 | 0.654652632 | ||
26 | 0.394505263 | 0.3384 | 0.899305263 | 1.310136842 | 1.041147368 | 0.949505263 | 0.551642105 | 0.781294737 | 0.776726316 | ||
27 | 0.941652632 | 0.586989474 | 0.319715789 | 1.453926316 | 0.7964 | 1.2198 | 0.420526316 | 0.756094737 | 0.460315789 | ||
28 | 0.367852632 | 0.329178947 | 0.540947368 | 0.846094737 | 0.332568421 | 1.817642105 | 0.378263158 | 0.369494737 | 0.668852632 | ||
29 | 1.050010526 | 0.430494737 | 1.166221053 | 0.576357895 | 0.180463158 | 1.127147368 | 0.801368421 | 0.692621053 | 0.621168421 | ||
30 | 0.712063158 | 0.549178947 | 0.889831579 | 1.479336842 | 1.025536842 | 0.930473684 | 0.707 | 0.7826 | 0.600610526 | ||
31 | 0.743705263 | 0.734747368 | 0.567389474 | 0.659631579 | 1.058936842 | 0.431726316 | 0.625621053 | 0.604536842 | 0.776052632 | ||
32 | 0.695894737 | 0.930578947 | 0.568084211 | 0.259326316 | 1.308147368 | 0.733926316 | 0.906705263 | 0.674557895 | 0.706378947 | ||
33 | 0.550473684 | 0.774063158 | 0.753610526 | 0.370315789 | 0.362821053 | 0.735136842 | 0.680757895 | 0.888347368 | 0.614789474 | ||
34 | 0.7444 | 0.751642105 | 0.588357895 | 0.467084211 | 0.612389474 | 0.930536842 | 0.373410526 | 0.498 | 0.309894737 | ||
35 | 0.484515789 | 1.161126316 | 0.3076 | 1.460736842 | 0.892094737 | 0.295673684 | 0.633084211 | 0.849536842 | 0.432557895 | ||
36 | 0.708515789 | 0.536147368 | 0.332157895 | 0.338305263 | 0.785936842 | 0.623747368 | 0.3342 | 0.572410526 | 0.315031579 | ||
37 | 0.553515789 | 0.622221053 | 0.5342 | 1.156242105 | 0.366252632 | 0.694568421 | 0.226831579 | 0.387115789 | 0.247863158 | ||
38 | 0.311378947 | 0.902684211 | 0.679842105 | 0.948189474 | 0.813063158 | 0.827305263 | 0.3768 | 0.386263158 | 0.392747368 | ||
39 | 0.651673684 | 0.629305263 | 1.106989474 | 0.603726316 | 0.259578947 | 0.701 | 0.556136842 | 0.478242105 | 0.309736842 | ||
40 | 1.431526316 | 0.356315789 | 1.080505263 | 1.162631579 | 0.448231579 | 0.650210526 | 0.354936842 | 0.289652632 | 0.324273684 | ||
41 | 0.402052632 | 0.761157895 | 0.954389474 | 0.8004 | 0.580884211 | 0.580884211 | 0.158157895 | 0.106252632 | 0.442789474 | ||
42 | 0.729484211 | 1.282242105 | 0.559063158 | 1.306084211 | 1.192884211 | 0.352178947 | 0.430673684 | 0.278010526 | 0.376136842 | ||
43 | 0.479378947 | 1.256736842 | 0.510263158 | 0.535052632 | 0.823221053 | 0.842873684 | 0.477031579 | 0.295189474 | 0.205515789 | ||
44 | 0.332421053 | 0.648915789 | 1.059663158 | 2.026884211 | 0.663157895 | 0.598726316 | 0.475842105 | 0.552242105 | 0.394178947 | ||
45 | 0.409442105 | 0.912357895 | 0.903894737 | 0.386642105 | 1.073031579 | 0.750484211 | 0.119336842 | 0.282684211 | 0.391536842 | ||
46 | 0.650452632 | 1.525757895 | 1.247610526 | 0.325326316 | 1.013589474 | 1.517968421 | 0.261547368 | 0.398894737 | 0.669821053 | ||
47 | 0.862210526 | 0.671431579 | 1.284326316 | 0.6668 | 0.602210526 | 0.465663158 | 0.277463158 | 0.433652632 | 0.219663158 | ||
48 | 0.393642105 | 0.714031579 | 0.505336842 | 0.679263158 | 0.335536842 | 0.608210526 | 0.209263158 | 1.065578947 | 0.260589474 | ||
49 | 1.038778947 | 0.531294737 | 0.466484211 | 0.487494737 | 0.372063158 | 0.708242105 | 0.4472 | 0.577873684 | 0.596968421 | ||
50 | 0.482052632 | 0.582357895 | 1.342821053 | 1.002642105 | 0.719515789 | 1.543821053 | 0.414652632 | 0.221652632 | 0.282031579 | ||
51 | 0.843221053 | 0.804484211 | 1.523905263 | 0.516557895 | 0.524884211 | 0.676831579 | 0.419126316 | 0.324568421 | 0.527789474 | ||
52 | 1.141336842 | 0.98 | 1.209421053 | 0.509126316 | 0.421915789 | 0.544 | 0.669157895 | 0.278357895 | 0.384505263 | ||
53 | 0.921968421 | 0.660852632 | 1.220747368 | 0.294957895 | 0.796673684 | 0.360021053 | 0.294042105 | 0.421147368 | 0.429736842 | ||
54 | 1.467884211 | 1.315031579 | 1.335884211 | 0.701010526 | 0.872926316 | 0.580757895 | 0.540389474 | 0.477821053 | 0.388452632 | ||
55 | 0.485663158 | 0.995031579 | 0.976673684 | 0.445315789 | 0.758673684 | 1.112168421 | 0.962726316 | 0.4834 | 0.584831579 | ||
56 | 0.896842105 | 0.707147368 | 0.666231579 | 1.503957895 | 0.347084211 | 1.433 | 0.472357895 | 0.672463158 | 0.459473684 | ||
57 | 0.911947368 | 1.010926316 | 0.504947368 | 0.889063158 | 0.914884211 | 0.474494737 | 0.532873684 | 0.452 | 0.617315789 | ||
58 | 1.008336842 | 0.9966 | 0.945873684 | 0.588842105 | 0.626578947 | 0.791715789 | 0.429494737 | 0.933263158 | 0.521063158 | ||
59 | 1.351936842 | 1.642631579 | 0.741631579 | 0.759347368 | 0.476484211 | 0.435242105 | 0.546168421 | 0.506873684 | 0.351568421 | ||
60 | 1.238736842 | 0.805652632 | 1.396315789 | 0.447442105 | 0.505126316 | 0.433936842 | 0.669557895 | 0.668705263 | 1.06 |